How we test
Every product on this site has been used by real women for real weeks before it gets a score. Here is the process.
The panel
Our testers are volunteers aged 40 to 72, recruited through reader emails and a small newsletter. Most are over 50. Each product goes to at least 12 testers. They keep notes in a short form after each use and fill in a longer questionnaire at the end.
The timeline
A review cycle runs about three months. The first month is getting to know the product. The second and third are about whether people keep reaching for it, how the battery holds up, and whether anything breaks or gets loud.
The five criteria
- Sensation. Does it feel good, and does it keep feeling good over weeks? We weigh "I kept using it" far more than first impressions.
- Ease. Can you use it without a manual, without a second hand, and without looking down?
- Build and care. Materials, seams, waterproofing, noise, and how long cleaning takes.
- Battery and reliability. Hours per charge and whether it is still working at week twelve.
- Value and risk. Price against what it does, plus the return policy if it isn't for you.
Scores and grades
Each criterion gets a percentage from the panel's averaged ratings. The ten-point score is the mean of the five. Grades follow school rules: A+ is 9.5 and up, A is 9.0, B+ is 8.5, B is 8.0, C+ is 7.5.
What we don't do
We don't accept payment for a placement, and brands don't see our copy before it goes live. We do earn commissions on some links; the disclosure page explains which and how that affects us.